Becoming a 21st Century School
  • Blog
    • 21st Century Schools site
    • LinkedIn Group
    • Curriculum
  • Schools
    • Schools
    • Inner Harbour
    • The Zoo School
    • Anne Frank Inspire Academy
  • 21st Century Schools
  • 21st Century Schools International
  • Global Collaborative Classrooms
  • Subscribe eNews

Exploring the Possibilities!

The purpose of the blog is to provide additional support to educators as well as parents and community members who wish to create schools which will provide children with the experiences needed to flourish!

​Anne Shaw, Director, 21st Century Schools

20th Century vs 21st Century Model of Education

8/22/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
​
In this post I am offering my perspectives on how education today remains firmly entrenched in what is often called the Factory Model, which was designed for the Industrial Revolution.  The majority of students at that time were educated to prepare for work on farms on in factories.  This is an obsolete model of a by-gone era.  But it is still with us today, well into the 21st century:

Picture
Now, take a look at the video below that was taken in a high school classroom in Texas in May of 2013.  Notice how the classroom is set up.  Notice the bare walls.  Notice that students are seated in rows - the Cemetery Method.  Notice that there is nothing on the students' desks.  Where is the teacher?  She is literally barricaded away from the students.  The reason the student in this video erupted in frustration was that the teacher refused to get up and help a student with a question she had about the "packet" of materials they were assigned to do.  According to the students' testimony online the teacher was playing Candy Crush on her computer.  

Probably not many teachers do that.  But, probably a lot of classrooms are set up and run in this manner - it's just "how we've always done things".  The rows of desks, packets of materials containing many facts to memorize, etc.  There are definitely no project-based, student-centered activities happening here.  This video was recorded by a student using his phone;  it was immediately uploaded to the Internet.


Please do not take my sharing this video with you as an accusation that teachers are lazy.  That's what this student said in the title of the video, and in this case, was probably correct.  Most teachers - the ones I've known - are extremely hardworking, dedicated and caring.  My point in sharing the video is to illustrate the factory model still in place.


Furthermore, the point is that students in the 21st century are frustrated with the factory model.  They know better!  Research has shown that the reasons 7,000 students drop out of school every day is that a.) school is boring, and b.) school is not relevant to their lives.  What are we going to do about that?  Ignore it?  I hope not!

If you visited 100 schools this semester you would probably see very similar classrooms! The crux of the problem as it stands today, in 2016, is this factory model.  This is the result of over 100 years of inertia and more recently, the NCLB, RTTT and the CCSS.  
Our schools have become nothing more than test prep centers;  perhaps test prep factories is more accurate. Teachers' jobs are to ensure that the students memorize as many facts as possible, as quickly as possible, and hopefully remember as many as possible for the test. Basically, we are force-feeding students discrete bits of information, with no regard as to their interests, skills, experiences or even the fact that they are human beings and not machines.


This whole paradigm, the factory model, began when schools adopted the Scientific Method created and marketed by Frederick Taylor in his monograph, Principles of Scientific Management published in 1911.  
​

Charlie Chaplin, one of the most innovative filmmakers of all time, and a social critic, said it best:


​That scene was about the "Eating Machine", from the film, Modern Times (1936).  The factory owners were trying to make everything, including eating, as efficient as possible. The Little Tramp character struggles to survive in the modern, industrialized world. The film is a comment on the desperate employment and financial conditions many people faced during the Great Depression, conditions created, in Chaplin's view, by the efficiencies of modern industrialization.[1]

Aren't we force feeding our students facts in the same way?  What comparisons can you think of between the Eating Machine feeding the Little Tramp, and today's standardized testing mania and our students?  Both the Little Tramp and our students are powerless;  notice that Charlie Chaplin is trapped/bound in the seat;  he has no choice or voice.  Do our students have any choice or voice in what or how they learn, or any choice related to standardized testing?  The testing and test prep is forced upon them just as the meal was forced upon the Little Tramp.


Did you notice the expressions of horror and confusion on the face of the Little Tramp? What  expressions appear upon the faces of today's students in relation to testing?

If we go back and check our university courses on Learning Theory, we will recall that real learning is not something that we "do to students";  rather, it is something that students DO - through trial and error, inquiry, making connections to previous experiences.  According to Piaget, Montessori, Dewey, and many more, learning is experiential and exploratory.
​
Memorizing massive amounts of facts is not learning.  Additionally, all our students already have access to any facts needed right in their pockets.
​
Below I have listed some of the ways we are maintaining the status quo of the factory model.  Then, I offer suggestions of what a 21st century model of education should be, and recommendations on how we can transition education into the 21st century.   


What are we still doing that needs to go?


  • Facilities are still "cells and bells" - school buildings are still, for the most part, constructed using nearly identical floor plans for the past 100 years. Long hallways are lined with lockers, and down the halls, on either side are rows of classrooms.  Student are sorted by age, then distributed into these "cells", moving from one cell to the next every 45 minutes or so - by the bell, as they did in factories.  Within each of these cells is a teacher and an assigned discipline such as science, history, or math, etc.
​
"First people shape the buildings, then the buildings shape the people."
​
Winston Churchill
Picture

​
  • Assembly Line Approach to Learning - everyone is expected to memorize exactly the same facts and acquire exactly the same basic level skills in exactly the same way, at exactly the same time.
​
Picture
 
  • Fragmented Curriculum - course content is organized by discipline.  I call this the Siloed Curriculum.  Each discipline is isolated from the other disciplines.  Schools are arranged by department, "and never the twain shall meet".
​
Picture

​
  • Standardization of everything from curriculum to assessment, i.e., testing.
​
Picture

  • Teacher-Centered - students are expected to learn by listening to the teacher's lectures and reading assigned material from standardized textbooks.  Students have no voice or choice in what or how they learn. Teachers have all the power in the classroom;  students have no power. How can anyone expect students to become independent, interdependent, self-directed, creative, critical thinkers in this environment? It is not possible.  Nor is it possible to provide personalized, student-centered learning experiences in the current structure.
​
Picture

  • Technology drives the curriculum, a/k/a App Fever - mistaking apps and their associated devices, for what is claimed to be "21st century education", is really nothing more than the factory model done digitally. The pedagogy remains the same, but the tools have changed.  A worksheet it still a worksheet - whether it is paper and pencil or digital - lower level skills and drills
​
  • Focus on Content - memorization of basic facts. 
​

What we should be doing instead . . . thinking "Wow, I could've had a V8!"
​



​Translation - "Instead of putting the students and myself through a year's worth of grinding through a boring curriculum, I could have been creating schedules and educational experiences which were relevant, rigorous, real world, engaging and motivational!"  

So, let's get rid of the obstacles and do what we know is best for kids and what works for actual learning!  Lose the "cells and bells"!  Get rid of the siloed curriculum.  Integrate the curriculum meaningfully.  This can be done by dropping some courses, combining others and letting students experience student-driven, interdisciplinary, project-based curriculum.


  • Restructure your campus by better organizing students, teachers within the spaces you have available.

  • Lose the "bell schedule" - create schedules that actually allow time for flexibility, true personalized learning, actual creativity, innovation, etc. 

  • If possible, build a new facility that supports 21st century modes of learning. Or, renovate older facilities.  If nothing else, reorganize your current physical spaces - you CAN create an oasis in the desert!

  • Let students learn all the required content standards, including the CCSS, by and through an engaging curriculum.
​
  • Stop kidding ourselves with fads, myths, legends and fallacies.  We have to stop trying to force fit bits and pieces of what might be "21st century" into business as usual.  Tweaking around the edges will not work.  

1.  From an article, Modern Times, in Wikipedia.


---------------------------------

​Anne Shaw is the Founder and Director of 21st Century Schools.  Our team is prepared to support you in transitioning your schools into the 21st century.  It is easier than you may think!

Please visit and “like” us on Facebook and Twitter


Director@21stCenturySchools.com

0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Subscribe to eNews
    Tweet

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    21st Century Schools
    American History
    Art
    Building Community
    Building Design
    Children's Literature
    Classroom Management
    Creativity
    Curriculum
    Ecoliteracy
    Emotional/Social
    Facilities
    First Day Of School
    Global Competencies
    High Expectations
    Math
    Media Literacy
    MOVE IT
    New York City
    PBL
    Physical Environment
    Play
    Professional Development
    Project-based Learning
    Reform
    Regioal Institute
    Service Learning
    STEAM
    Sugata Mitra
    Workshop

    .

    Archives

    February 2018
    August 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    May 2016
    December 2015
    October 2015
    July 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    October 2013
    August 2013
    April 2013
    January 2013
    September 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    January 2012
    January 2011

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Blog
    • 21st Century Schools site
    • LinkedIn Group
    • Curriculum
  • Schools
    • Schools
    • Inner Harbour
    • The Zoo School
    • Anne Frank Inspire Academy
  • 21st Century Schools
  • 21st Century Schools International
  • Global Collaborative Classrooms
  • Subscribe eNews